I overheard an interesting conversation in the Library this evening. Mackenzie was lecturing the Several Annies on the history of private libraries such as ours down the centuries in the British Isles. (He claimed that ours is the oldest known, but that can’t be verified.)
A Several Annie wanted to know if there was a Unified Theory of Libraries, a metanarrative, she said, that connected all the libraries in existence, past and present. I don’t know if she was pulling his leg, but it certainly was an interesting question, one that made me stop and wait for his answer.
He said after a long silence, ‘I have a tale to tell of a Christmastide Ceilidh here in the Great Hall. One of the players, a pretty red-headed fiddler dressed all in green, remarked that the building and its inhabitants formed what she called a ‘tea cup culture’ in that one could learn all one needed to know about what was going on here over a cup of tea and a tatty scone or two while sitting in the kitchen on a winter’s afternoon gossiping with the staff.
‘Couldn’t disagree with her, as I’ve heard more interesting news over a few pints of Little Sir John Ale than bears ‘membering. Some of it is rather mundane — oh, a musician telling another musician that their band which was River Gods is now called Grendel’s Den as they’ve added a carnyx player to the band and the sound is really dark now.
‘Or the concertina player with Nobody’s Wedding Guests was telling the tale of what she called the ‘blood wedding’ where everything went wrong. I’m still not sure the priest could have done that, but Reynard, anti-papist that he is, says anything is possible with a priest. Especially a defrocked one. Maybe that was why it all went wrong!
Librarians exist in a tea cup culture of their own, one connected by letter and telegraph across the civilized world that allowed them to know each other and share gossip and information as need be. If there is a Unified Theory of Libraries, it’s based on the long established fact that any librarian worth his or her salt is curious about everything. Oh, they have their areas of keen interest; e.g., there’s a Norwegian librarian I know who has collected bloody near every printed work on trolls she could find. Justina, our consulting potter, used her as a resource for the Troll Under the Bridge project. I’d not heard of her but a librarian I knew in London knew another librarian who remembered her interest in trolls, as he talked with her while at a conference in Iceland a decade back.
So it’s not really that there’s a Unified Theory of Libraries, but more that they are all interconnected by shared interests and passions that are strengthened by the odd conference, the papers we write, the Internet discussion groups, the busman’s holiday spent visiting other libraries, and the exchanges we do among staff. And all of you who are Several Annies will in turn become part of that tea cup culture as you settle into your careers in libraries and elsewhere.’
I’ll need to think about what he said. Much might be true, but I’m not sure how truly unique that tea cup culture is, as I’d say any profession, such as the musicians he mentioned, form a similar one. Certainly there’s a network of Estate Gardeners who share stories and seeds and gossip as I’m part of it.
Tills nästa gång
Gus



What’s New for the 12th of April: Some new and recent SF; new Americana, Norwegian folk rock and jazz; and thoughts on War For The Oaks
Emma Bull in her War for the Oaks novel
It’s a good evening to re-read one of my favourite novels, so let’s talk about War for the Oaks, Emma Bull’s novel beloved by oh so many. As Michael says, ‘In 1987, Emma Bull revolutionized the way we look at the world around us with her debut novel, War for the Oaks , a no-holds-barred, fast-paced, magically written rock-and-roll fable about Eddi McCandry, a Minneapolis singer/musician who gets dragged into a supernatural war taking place out of mortal sight.’
I really like the novel because it takes a real setting which is the Minneapolis and imposed it upon it a fantasy reality in a way that city stays real. I’ve not been to Minneapolis but I’ve got friends there who say that you can recognise everything in the novel because she didn’t change anything.
The characters, fey and human alike, feel quite real. Eddie, our human guitarist here, is a remarkable character, fully realised in a way that fantasy characters generally aren’t. That’s not to say that the other character that are here aren’t.
The story itself, the best one she ever is told though I am very fond of Finder, her story set in Terri Windling’s Bordertown universe. yes as a supernatural war going on but the interpersonal conflicts here are just as important and definitely told by her in a way that keeps them as important as the overarching theme is.
I’ve got on at some length about this at this point so let me stop here and say just go read the novel. copies of the original edition are still available out there unreasonable price, and Tor did a hardcover edition which has some rather great artwork as well though it officially never came out. no idea why but I’ve an autographed one here. I didn’t say it wasn’t published, just that it didn’t officially come out.
Gary finally got around to reading James S. A. Corey’s first book in The Expanse series. ‘I greatly enjoyed Leviathan Wakes, racing through its 500-some pages in near record time, and plan to proceed through all nine of the series novels published so far. (Taking time out, of course, for the upcoming installments in their new The Captives’ War series.)’
He also enjoyed the action and humor in a new book just out this month. ‘Award winning author Suzanne Palmer adds to her growing stack of novel-length SF with Ode to the Half-Broken, an engaging tale of friendship and treachery, adventure and revenge among post-apocalypse AI “mechs” and a few surviving humans in what used to be the United States.
And some Archival SF reviews, starting with Cat’s take on Larry Niven’s Rainbow Mars. ‘Ah, to visit John Carter and the inhabitants of Barsoom, Edger Rice Burroughs’ richly imagined Mars. The characters in Robert Heinlein’s The Number of The Beast did so, in their travels across the multiverse, and now the protaganist of Rainbow Mars does it. Well, sort of.’
Next, Kathleen’s look at Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle’s Inferno. ‘They just aren’t the writers one would expect to essay a modern version of Dante Alighieri’s The Divine Comedy. And that’s a shame, because Inferno is one of the better books either of them has written. It is clever but also wise, which is very rare in science fiction.’
And Gary’s review of the sequel, Escape From Hell. ‘I found myself wishing that the authors had delved a bit further into an obvious potential explanation for the existence of Hell — something that would incorporate quantum physics and the kind of ideas explored by Heinlein and others.’
It’s me, Gary, with some new music. I’ve been listening to some good Americana music lately, including the new release from Cincinnati based duo The Montvales. ‘They wrote most of the songs on Path of Totality, their third album, on a 2024 cross country tour that coincided with a solar eclipse, and themes like darkness, light and shadow, poverty and living on the margins, and making community where you find it run through these 12 songs.’
‘I was surprised, perhaps even shocked, to learn that It Runs Deep is the Garrett Boys’ debut album,’ I say in my next review. ‘This collection of deeply rooted and deeply personal songs is one of the best old time Americana records I’ve heard in some time.’
‘My favorite head-banging Norwegian metal prog folk rock band is back!’ as I note in this next review. ‘Gangar’s second full-length Dreng continues in their established vein of playing knock-em-dead versions of Scandinavian folk songs and dance tunes on Hardanger fiddle plus rock instruments.’
I also cover some jazz, of course, starting with saxophonist Mark Turner’s latest for ECM. ‘A tight yet flexible boundary between improvisation and control is one of the central features of this amazing, sophisticated, and engaging album from Mark Turner’s quartet. Every one of Turner’s six compositions on Patternmaster swings back and forth from tightly composed chamber jazz to high-wire soloing and back with jaw-dropping ease. It’s a document of a composer, bandleader and ensemble in peak form.’
‘After recording their first album from within the claustrophic confines of pandemic enforced digital collaboration, the American jazz quarter Triple Blind’s second effort is all about reconnecting,’ I opine in this next one. ‘They recorded together live in the well known Dreamland Recording Studios in an old church near Woodstock, New York, and the resulting album Cold Walk comes with an invitingly spontaneous and organic feel.’
Our musical offering is ‘For It All which is from the Another Way To Travel album by Cats Laughing, used here courtesy of Will Shetterly. We’ve reviewed both of their albums here, of which the Another Way To Travel album is by far the best. Years later after the band was no longer, they came together again and released a CD and DVD, A Long Time Gone: Reunion at MiniCon. The concert’s fun, the rest of the material here is great.